A Critical Realist Approach to Integrating Human Rights into Health Impact Assessment

Download files
Access & Terms of Use
open access
Embargoed until 2019-10-31
Copyright: Haigh, Fiona
Altmetric
Abstract
Objective To conceptualise a practically adequate theory and methodology of Human Rights Health Impact Assessment (HRHIA) using critical realist (CR) ontological perspectives and research approaches. Research design A CR framework for theory development and verification was applied. It involved four interrelated and iterative steps: description and analytic resolution of events and their effects; explication of structure using abductive and retroductive reasoning; assessment of explanatory power and contextualisation; and verification and concretisation of emergent theory. Application of the framework involved analysis and theorising of data from 23 international human rights (HR) and health impact assessment (HIA) experts; existing case studies of HIAs (11 case studies, 33 interviews) and a HR-based initiative (1 case study, 12 interviews); my own recollections and introspections on HIA projects; and relevant literature. Findings A methodology is conceptualised as an entity with specific properties that give it the power to guide an overall process intended to achieve a defined outcome or purpose. Methodologies can exist in four states: conceptualised, intended, enacted, and experienced. The properties that empower the guidance mechanisms of a methodology include interrelated points of view concerning: the (health rights) environment that the methodology is intended to respond to and influence; relevant knowledge properties of people involved in use of the methodology; the intended purpose and goals of the methodology; the methodology rationale; conceptual frameworks about HRHIA and HR environments that inform decision-making; processes for enacting the methodology that subsume methods, tools and conditions associated with their use; and criteria and standards for evaluating the methodology, and the outcomes when the methodology is enacted. This definition and framework were used to develop an HRHIA-specific methodology framework (state 1) and some aspects of an intended methodology (state 2). The latter included development of a procedural model and identification of potential mechanisms associated with its implementation. Conclusion This research demonstrates that a theory and methodology for HRHIA can be conceptualised using a critical realist theorising framework. The research makes a significant contribution to scholarship associated with the application of a CR paradigm in the contexts of HRHIA and methodology development.
Persistent link to this record
Link to Publisher Version
Link to Open Access Version
Additional Link
Author(s)
Haigh, Fiona
Supervisor(s)
Bazeley, Patricia
Kemp, Lynn
Creator(s)
Editor(s)
Translator(s)
Curator(s)
Designer(s)
Arranger(s)
Composer(s)
Recordist(s)
Conference Proceedings Editor(s)
Other Contributor(s)
Corporate/Industry Contributor(s)
Publication Year
2017
Resource Type
Thesis
Degree Type
PhD Doctorate
UNSW Faculty
Files
download public version.pdf 7.28 MB Adobe Portable Document Format
Related dataset(s)